The Dam Difference for Fish

OPB | Nov. 10, 2008 midnight | Updated: Sept. 10, 2013 8:46 p.m.

What does a new study say about the effect of dams on fish?

Environmental groups have said for decades that hydroelectric dams are a hazard for fish. Now, a new study calls that long-held claim into question. The study, published last week, tracked salmon and steelhead migrating to the ocean through eight dams along the Snake and Columbia rivers. It also tracked fish traveling out to sea via Canada’s Fraser River, which does not have any dams. Scientists found the survival rate of fish migrating through the Columbia and Snake rivers to be higher than that of the fish on the Fraser.

Scientists and conservation groups are still debating how the new study’s results should be interpreted. David Welch, the study’s lead author, says the data suggests that ocean conditions could be more to blame than dams for the decrease in salmon populations. His colleague and fellow study author, Oregon State University professor Carl Schreck, says the evidence points to the strong possibility of unforeseen problems with the Fraser River.

What’s your take on this surprising new study? What do you want to ask the scientists who worked on it? And does this most recent wrinkle in the Northwest’s salmon saga change your relationship with rivers, fish, and hydroelectric power?

GUESTS:

Photo credit: poloballs / Flickr / Creative Commons

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus
Thanks to our Sponsors:
become a sponsor

Related

Thanks to our Sponsors
become a sponsor

Funding Provided By

Rose E. Tucker Charitable Trust

James F. and Marion L. Miller Foundation

Dawn and Al Vermeulen

Ray and Marilyn Johnson