US-Canada border closure likely to be ‘with us for a while’

By Tom Banse (Northwest News Network)
Nov. 18, 2020 2:29 p.m.

The most recent extension of the U.S.-Canada border closure expires this Friday, but no one expects the restrictions to be lifted then. First implemented in March, the closure of the land and sea border to nonessential crossings have been extended monthly by mutual agreement between Ottawa and the Trump administration.

In a radio interview on Tuesday, Canadian ambassador to the U.S. Kirsten Hillman declined to speculate when the border might reopen, but it won’t be soon.

Cross-border traffic at the Peace Arch and other places along the U.S.-Canada border has fallen dramatically since nonessential crossings were limited due to the pandemic.

Cross-border traffic at the Peace Arch and other places along the U.S.-Canada border has fallen dramatically since nonessential crossings were limited due to the pandemic.

Tom Banse / NW News Network, file photo

"The pandemic seems to be escalating in both of our countries," Hillman said. "That would seem to suggest that these measures are with us for a while."

Hillman said she was happy to hear concrete proposals from business and trade groups in the Pacific Northwest for how to safely ease the border closure in the future. An initial pilot project that just launched in Alberta uses rapid COVID-19 testing to shorten quarantines for arriving travelers.

Hillman cautioned that getting back to normal will be a gradual process, not like flipping a switch.

Truck drivers and so-called “essential” workers in fields like health care and energy are permitted to cross the border as normal as long as they have no symptoms. Canada, unlike the U.S. , enforces a mandatory 14-day quarantine for all other arriving or returning travelers.

The ban on discretionary cross-border travel and the quarantine requirement has choked off most business travel and just about all tourist travel. That has caused significant hurt at favorite haunts of American visitors, such as British Columbia’s Victoria and Vancouver, and at Canadian shopping destinations such as Washington’s Bellingham and Spokane.

Earlier on Tuesday, Hillman and her American counterpart in Ottawa, acting U.S. ambassador Katherine Brucker, held a listening session with Pacific Northwest representatives from the tourism, travel and trade sectors. During that virtual meeting (co-hosted by the Pacific Northwest Economic Region and Victoria-based South Island Prosperity Partnership), speakers implored the ambassadors and their respective federal governments to consider ideas to adjust the border restrictions.

Hillman said in the subsequent radio interview that the variable progression of the COVID-19 pandemic makes it difficult to cite specific benchmarks or disease metrics that the governments will use to guide their border reopening decisions.

"There aren't specific metrics where we can say, 'If it hits X level, we'll make Y decision,'" Hillman said. "That's not how it works. It's a little bit more of a conversation."


An expert on the U.S.-Canada relations said as time goes on, it would be good to give more public guidance on the plans for a phased border reopening to let the business community prepare for the return of tourism and cross-border shopping, for example.

“We need to offer that kind of signaling. I think it is an essential part of the management of this pandemic,” Christopher Sands, director of the Wilson Center’s Canada Institute, said during a webinar. “We just haven’t seen that from the federal governments. I’m hopeful we will see that now.”

Sands said he has the impression there is strong popular support in both countries to keep crossing restrictions in place for the time being to contain the risk of a worse wave of new coronavirus infections.

The lengthy U.S.-Canada land border is normally the busiest in the world. But due to the pandemic-related crossing restrictions, the Canadian government says traffic across the border has fallen between 80%-95%, depending on the zone. Truck traffic has remained close to pre-pandemic levels under rules designed to maintain international supply chains.

Earlier this month, the Canadian federal government and the province of Alberta launched a pilot project to shorten the required quarantine period for international travelers. The trial allows eligible travelers arriving at two locations — Calgary International Airport and the Interstate 15 land border crossing between Sweet Grass, Montana, and Coutts, Alberta, to take a free COVID-19 test there. A trial participant must quarantine at a residence until the test results come back in around two days. Should the test results come back negative, then the person can leave quarantine and go about their business in Alberta. Participants need to take a second test six or seven days after arrival to reconfirm the earlier negative result.

“The start of this unique trial is a significant first step in giving peace of mind to those who need to travel and were apprehensive due to the rigorous quarantine requirements and testing restrictions,” WestJet Chief Commercial Officer Arved von zur Muehlen said in a statement on Nov. 2.

WestJet plans to resume Portland to Calgary airline service in early January, alongside a gradual ramp up in its international flights. The carrier currently offers limited flights from its Calgary hub to three U.S. destinations — Los Angeles, Palm Springs and Phoenix.

The executive director of the group Pacific Northwest Economic Region, Matt Morrison, said other pilot projects are being planned to revive cross-border air, land and sea travel, including one focused on short hop flights between Seattle and Vancouver, B.C. That air travel project envisions multi-layered pre-travel COVID-19 testing of passengers.

Elsewhere along the northern border, the outlook is unchanged for the isolated enclave of Point Roberts, Washington. The only road connection to the stub of U.S. land attached to the Vancouver suburbs goes through British Columbia. Point Roberts residents — and Canadians who own second homes on the peninsula — want the enclave exempted from the limits on nonessential border crossings.

Ambassador Hillman said she was very familiar with the predicament of Point Roberts, not least because her mother lives close by in South Surrey, British Columbia.

“Discretionary travel is important to all people, including you and I,” Hillman said. “But right now, that travel is being limited for all Canadians and all Americans coming to Canada, including residents of Point Roberts.”

Because of the ongoing border closure, a Port of Bellingham spokesman said the port will continue a temporary ferry service to the isolated peninsula through the winter, as weather conditions allow. The port chartered a 100-passenger eco-tour boat to provide twice-weekly, passenger-only ferry service between the Point Roberts marina and the Bellingham Cruise Terminal. The free service, which requires advance reservations, began in August.

“It has been very well received by the folks in Point Roberts,” said Port of Bellingham spokesman Mike Hogan. “The port commission has directed us to continue providing service until the Canadian border opens to nonessential travel or until they decide differently.”


Related Stories

Oregon and Washington both have new COVID-19 restrictions. Here’s how they compare

As Oregon and Washington experience sharp rises in new cases of COVID-19, Oregon Gov. Kate Brown and Washington Gov. Jay Inslee have both enacted statewide restrictions on businesses and gatherings to slow the spread of the virus. But the rules going into effect this week have some key differences, depending on what side of the state line you're on.