Officials in New York, California, and elsewhere say they’ll fight Attorney General Jeff Sessions’ move to cut off billions in federal grant money to cities that don’t share the Trump administration’s strict approach to enforcing immigration laws.
“The Trump Administration is pushing an unrealistic and mean spirited executive order,” New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio tweeted last night. “If they want a fight, we’ll see them in court.”
In Seattle, Mayor Ed Murray said, “I’m willing to risk losing every penny of federal funding to stand by our commitment to protect everyone in our community.”
Seattle’s Welcoming Cities policies, Murray said, are a way to help the local community “by assisting residents on the path to citizenship and warmly integrating immigrant schoolchildren into our classrooms.”
Leaders in other cities, from San Francisco to Chicago and Washington, D.C., have also said they won’t agree to the demands that were laid out in an executive order signed by President Trump. Days after it was signed, San Francisco sued the Trump administration.
As reporter Danielle Karson tells NPR from Los Angeles, California’s Senate President Pro Tem Kevin de León says the state won’t go along with what he calls “blackmail.”
“Singling out cities and states with punitive threats is unconstitutional,” de León said. “Withholding federal resources is unconstitutional. We’ll not hesitate to fight him, and settle the matter in court.”
Explaining part of the potential legal fight, Karson adds, “Legal experts say the Constitution’s 10th Amendment forbids the feds from ‘commandeering’ state and local governments to enforce federal mandates.”
By threatening to withhold as much as $4.1 billion in federal grants Monday, Sessions targeted cities and towns where local law enforcement agencies take steps such as refusing to honor detainment orders from Immigration and Customs Enforcement unless the orders also include a warrant or court order that establishes probable cause.
“Such policies cannot continue,” Sessions said, as NPR’s Jessica Taylor reported. “They make our nation less safe by putting dangerous criminals back on our streets.”
As Jessica also noted, several studies have shown immigrants to be less likely than native-born Americans to commit a crime.
The push to use funding as a way to force cities to crack down on illegal immigration could affect 118 jurisdictions — that’s how many cities and counties ICE recently said had rejected requests to detain immigrants.
As a map created by the Center for Immigration Studies shows, while many of those jurisdictions are clumped on America’s coasts, dozens of them are scattered around the country, with concentrated areas in states such as Iowa and Colorado.