science environment

Lab Results Show Wallowa Lake Free Of Herbicide Barrel Contaminants

By Erin Ross (OPB)
June 27, 2019 7 p.m.

UPDATE (June 27, 4:46 p.m. PT) — After almost 10 months of waiting, residents of Joseph, Oregon, can feel more confident drinking their water and swimming in nearby Wallowa Lake, according to lab test results released Thursday.

The town, located in Oregon's northeast corner, had stopped drawing drinking water from the lake 15 days prior, when the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency first began investigating a number of 55-gallon drums found at the bottom of the lake, thought to contain toxic herbicides. Test results are back, and the barrels and lake water seem to be contaminant-free.

The U.S. EPA removes a barrel from Wallowa Lake.

The U.S. EPA removes a barrel from Wallowa Lake.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

The barrels were discovered last August by recreational divers. In all, there were 74 drums and barrels, including one that was labeled "2,4-D or 2,4,5-T." Combined at military strengths, those two herbicides create Agent Orange, a chemical defoliant widely used by the United States military during the Vietnam War with devastating, long-lasting consequences for the landscape and the people who lived in it.


“They conflated the herbicide with Agent Orange,” EPA spokesperson Bill Dunbar said. “It’s easy to see how that could happen with a Google search.”

The divers brought the barrels to the attention of the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality after they were found, but removal work didn't begin until June 12 of this year.

As the agency began removing barrels, it began to appear that the situation may not have been as bad as divers and environmental officials had initially feared. The barrel's label suggested it contained one or the other herbicide used to make Agent Orange — but not both — and it lacked the orange stripe used to signify military-strength chemicals. Most of the barrels were unlabeled and seemed to be empty.

“It was clear that all of these drums had been in the lake for quite some time. They were deteriorated pretty significantly,” Dunbar said. The EPA initially reported that some of the drums appeared to be intact, but once the drums were brought to the surface, it was clear that if there ever had been something hazardous in them, it was long gone.

The EPA took 15 samples of lake water. Eleven of those samples were from the surface of the lake, three were from the city of Joseph’s drinking water plant, and one sample was from the water inside the drum with the herbicide label. Because pesticides can sometimes linger longer in soil, the EPA also tested the sediment at the bottom of the lake where the drums were found. All of the samples came back clean, according to the EPA and the DEQ.

“I can’t say there was never any hazardous substance,” Dunbar said, “but if there was, it was long gone.”

It’s very unlikely the drums were just dumped in the lake, Dunbar said. Drums like this, when filled with air, are used as floats for docks and mooring boats. They’re also filled with water or cement and sunk as anchors. Since all the drums were found near the modern-day marina, that’s probably how they ended up in Wallowa Lake, Dunbar said.