Last week, the city of Umatilla voted to declare a state of emergency in response to Gov. Tina Kotek’s data center moratorium. The city says preventing future data centers could cost their community millions. Data centers have drawn growing bipartisan opposition across the country. They’ve also created increasing concern for Oregonians on both sides of the aisle. Umatilla City Manager Dave Stockdale joins us to share more on the state of emergency and the state moratorium’s broader impacts.
Note: The following transcript was transcribed digitally and validated for accuracy, readability and formatting by an OPB volunteer.
Dave Miller: From the Gert Boyle Studio at OPB, this is Think Out Loud. I’m Dave Miller. Data centers have seen a growing and bipartisan backlash across the country, including in Oregon. That’s what led Democratic Governor Tina Kotek and her Republican challenger State Senator Christine Drazan to both call for moratoriums on new data centers. But some rural communities are pushing back. Last week, the city of Umatilla voted to declare a state of emergency. It says the governor’s moratorium could cost them millions.
Dave Stockdale is the Umatilla city manager. He joins us now. It’s great to have you on the show.
Dave Stockdale: Yeah, thanks for having me. I really appreciate it.
Miller: Before we get to the moratorium and your emergency declaration, can you just first give us a sense for the existing footprint of data centers in the city of Umatilla?
Stockdale: Sure. So we’ve had [data centers] in the city for over 15 years now, so they’re not a new industry to us. We currently have three data center facilities that are fully operational, one data center facility that we would say is about 50% completed and so partially operational. Another data center facility that’s under construction and, until October 9, was anticipated to be on schedule to receive its certificate of occupancy late second quarter next year, probably May or June. And then we have two additional data center facilities that are under enterprise zone contract agreements, and were anticipated to break ground, one in 2027 and the other in early 2028. So, seven total at very different stages of the process.
Miller: Right, three fully operational, one partially, and then the three others that are in various stages of either planning or construction. We spent a week in Hermiston this past summer and toured around the broader area as well in the county. We saw, just in the city of Hermiston, the effects of Amazon money. It helped fund a new city hall, improvements to the library where we broadcast from, other capital improvements. What kind of impact has money from data center projects had in Umatilla?
Stockdale: Yeah, it’s been rather substantial. Prior to 2019, where we completed a more than $6 million road improvement project in partnership with ODOT, there hadn’t been a single road improvement project in the city for more than two decades. So, 2019 was kind of the first year, the beginning of these capital improvement impacts. We had a transportation project for that along the highway.
We just completed earlier this year, in May … we cut the ribbon on our brand new Umatilla Business Center. This was an $8.2 million project, and we borrowed no money to pay for it. It was funded by proceeds from enterprise zone agreements, as well as we were successful in leveraging those enterprise zone funds to leverage federal dollars from the Federal EDA (Economic Development Administration), and through direct appropriations through the state legislature. That business center houses our brand new business incubator program. So we have three businesses operating out of there that pay well below market rental rates, in exchange for education equity. We provide trainings, in partnership with the Chamber of Commerce and other business resources, to help them in things like putting together business plans, tax preparation, marketing, advertisement and so on.
That also led to, just outside that building, we have our Village Square Plaza. We opened up this summer, for the first time ever, our summer Saturday Market and Concert Series. We have over 25 vendors that participate in that each month. We’ve had between 500 and 1,000 [people], depending on the month, that came to that on Saturday.
And then on top of that now, perhaps one of the biggest things where this has the impact is we’ve broke ground and are midway through construction of a brand new police station. The voters in November of last year approved a bond measure to build a new modern day police station facility. Our current one, some of the building’s 30 years old, some of it’s 40 years old. It’s a modular that’s sort of put together and was never designed to be a police station. So the new building is, like I said, about halfway through.
As part of our financial strategy on that bond, we let the voters know that a “yes” vote, just because of the mere financial impact of these data centers, that the data centers would be paying for the vast majority of that bond payment. And then we set up that we would even do, to the residential taxpayer, a refund of what they paid into that bond, using enterprise zone proceeds to pay for that.
So we’ve had several of those projects done. We even built a brand new park at Nugent Park last year. That was a $2.1 million park with a new Little League baseball field, scoreboard, playground, pavilion, bathroom, open space, and some new trail projects as well. So it’s been a rather substantial impact.
Miller: Does it ever feel like this is too good to be true?
Stockdale: Well, it’s a very interesting question. There’s an argument out there about data centers don’t really create a lot of jobs. And that comment is both true and false at the same time. One thing that’s really interesting is, from a city perspective – which is likely different from the state – if you want to maintain your sort of small town values, one of the things that’s great with the data center is the fact that its job creation is somewhat moderate…
Miller: That’s exactly what we heard from your counterpart in Hermiston, that it’s a benefit, not a drawback that this doesn’t create a ton of jobs.
I should say I was focused less on the job piece and more on … You’ve just outlined all of these projects that are either underway or completed, all of these civic goods that you’re able to provide or improve because of this money from this one source. I guess I’m just thinking broadly, both how much you worry about too many eggs in one basket, and then relatedly, how much you worry about that basket breaking?
Stockdale: Yeah, we get that comment or question a lot too. And the risk is never zero, of course not, that’s just not possible. But one of the things that I think that is not necessarily realized, and I think that’s part of what our narrative is here with this declaration, is that what might appear like the building just sort of pops up one day overnight, by the time that we actually get to that point, we’re talking years in the making and discussions, and so on. And when these campuses are built, they’re investments with billions of dollars of investment. These are hard things to pick up and walk away from for this very reason. There’s local permitting, federal permitting, state permitting, site planning and so forth. All of these things come into account when they pick and develop their site.
And then of course, these facilities are more or less warehouses, and the technology changes. So the space is adequate in what they need. If they have the permits in hand, they don’t have to spend all of that time, money and resources to build them up. They simply replace the technology that’s inside. So when I was in Lane County 20 years ago, we had a company out there called Hynix, and they developed semiconductor microchips for a lot of the chips in your Samsung phones. And when that chip becomes obsolete, that company went under and went out.
Well, this is not like that. There isn’t a widget per se that’s produced by a data center. It’s capacity, it’s storage. The technology of storage gets better and better. There’s more power in your cell phone than there was on the Apollo missions. And the operation of the facility gets more and more efficient, less water, less energy and so on as the technology continues to improve. So, the risk is not zero. But the likelihood of walking away from a multi-billion dollar investment, from doing the worksource job creation and local training of employees, and the fact that there’s not a specific type of widget produced, the risks start to become significantly less.
Miller: Let’s turn now to the emergency declaration that the city council approved last week. What’s the basic idea behind it?
Stockdale: There’s really a handful of major ideas here. One, it’s a formal recognition of a very real financial threat. To be clear, the city has not spent a penny of any money from these potential future data centers getting their certificate of occupancy and being here. But we have been prudent fiscal managers. We do financial planning. And we have capital improvement plans and master plans, for example, and we create implementation strategies based upon those forecasts. So the very threat is enough to create the significant financial and economic harm to our community. And in this case, we see that as potentially several billions of dollars of private investment and several millions of dollars of both operational revenue that would come to the city, the county and other taxing districts, as well as millions of dollars in developer-funded infrastructure payments…
Miller: To go back to the list that you started with, you have three fully operational data centers, one partially operational, one under construction, two under various kinds of contract agreements. What would the moratorium mean for the four data centers that are either not yet built or not yet fully operational? And I imagine it’s complicated, if you can give us sort of the high level version of that answer please.
Stockdale: Yeah, you bet. The crux of it really comes down to the WPCF or the Water Pollution Control Facility permit, or the NPDES permit, the National Pollution Discharge Elimination System permit. So, those are kind of two things. The facilities permit is what it sounds like. Any type of facility associated with the discharge of wastewater requires that review and approval. If there’s the NPDES permit, if there’s anything at the federal level on the actual discharge.
So those four, the one that’s partially operating and the one that’s under construction … The one that’s partially operating has some of their facilities permit, which allowed them to begin operations under a temporary certificate of occupancy. But it doesn’t have a NPDES permit. And the other one that’s under construction, anticipated to be opened in about six months from now, it has neither. And that isn’t because they haven’t been working through the process or making the applications. We have, it’s just that these things consistently and frequently happen simultaneously. If you look at it, as anyone who’s familiar with project management, you’re looking at 20 different columns of activities. So these things work side by side, simultaneously.
Miller: Do you think, to go to the even higher view of this, this moratorium would lead to just a delay of some of these projects? Or the end of them?
Stockdale: These are the seven that we have currently under some kind of contract. We have other data center industries that we are talking to and have been talking to for a number of years, while they do run through their due diligence on site selection, site availability and so on, which isn’t even in any of our correspondence so far. Those that we’re talking to have certainly said that the instability or the unknown right now is too much, and so they’ve paused their discussions with us since October 9.
No one has said that they’re withdrawing from the city of Umatilla, although that isn’t true for our neighbors in Hermiston. But the delay itself – If we went till July 1, an eight-month delay is not just an eight month delay. The way that these are set, once they get their C of O is when it triggers all these additional payments as part of their agreement. So, if they get their C of O in 2027, they start making payments in 2028. If there’s a delay till July, but it was gonna take me another six months now, that pushes me into 2028 to get their C of O, which means they’re not making a payment till ‘29.
What that means is there’s millions of dollars upfront on the delay, which delays other projects. The cost of materials and the cost of labor continue to go up year over year. It’s always cheaper, as we talk about capital improvement, to build now than to build tomorrow. So it’s sort of this domino effect or capitalization effect of the financial impact.
And then on the back end, when they come out of the abatement program, you’re talking tens of millions of dollars that are paid to the local taxing districts that is now delayed another year, again, capitalized over time. So there’s the immediate financial threat today, and then there’s kind of the back end of the agreement financial threat because of the delays as well.
Miller: Tina Kotek and Christine Drazan both came out in favor of moratoriums of some kind for new data centers, I think within 24 hours of each other. How does it feel to be in this relatively rare position where you’re pushing back against the leaders of both major parties?
Stockdale: Cities in general are nonpartisan, and of course we’re acutely aware of the politics that surround out there. The city is not asking for any kind of special treatment at all whatsoever. In fact, kind of to the contrary. We’ve always been very strong supporters of environmental policies and solutions. We’ve been fully compliant with the EPA and DEQ’s regulations, and we consider our relationship with those organizations very, very good. We meet with them very often because of these projects.
One of the things that’s tough for us is our greatest strength has kind of become our greatest weakness. One of the things that we’re quite proud of in Umatilla is that, it’s true, data centers, depending on what metric you look at, certainly use a lot of water. But our water is reused. We have partnerships with the Bureau of Reclamation and the West Extension Irrigation District where any of the water that comes into the data center, about 90% of it, ends up for beneficial reuse through the irrigation district canal. And that water right can be used for regular farmlands that have a water right, or it can go on to otherwise scab property that doesn’t have a water right that now can create a crop. And so our reuse has actually created about an extra 240 acres of additional crop land developed by farmers here in the region, and we’ve been doing ag for over a couple hundred years here now.
So the symbiotic relationship is quite there. What’s really interesting for us is because of our reuse, the way that we have our permits set up with our NPDES permit, using the canal for reuse has now become the thing that’s actually hindering our ability to get these permits to move forward. It’s a weird paradox for us when we look at it as something that we’re proud of, because our water doesn’t have the nitrate issues that some of the stuff has in the regions here. We test it frequently and rigorously, and we don’t have those pollutants and contaminants that are there, which is why we’re fully compliant with the EPA and DEQ. This is a better quality water for farming, no nitrates additional on the water, and no suspended solids and things like that. So, it’s a very interesting position for us to be in, when you look at [how] some of our greatest water stewardship is now actually the thing that’s hindering us the most.
Miller: Dave Stockdale, thanks very much for your time today.
Stockdale: Really appreciate it. Thank you.
Miller: Dave Stockdale is the city manager of Umatilla. Last week, the city declared a state of emergency in response to the governor’s moratorium on data centers.
“Think Out Loud®” broadcasts live at noon every day and rebroadcasts at 8 p.m.
If you’d like to comment on any of the topics in this show or suggest a topic of your own, please get in touch with us on Facebook, send an email to thinkoutloud@opb.org, or you can leave a voicemail for us at 503-293-1983.
